Question Time and Nick Griffin Share an Andy Warhol Moment

Nick Griffin

The BBC’s Question Time programme and Nick Griffin, leader of the right-wing British Nationalist Party, share a hugely insignificant event

Question Time is a venerable BBC chat show. This week it became the centre of a political story through its decision to invite Nick Griffin, leader of the right-wing British Nationalist Party to take part.

The programme format is to have a group of B-celebrities discuss current affairs under the avuncular chairmanship of David Dimbleby and interaction with an audience which is groomed to produce questions, pass comment, and generally exercise the appropriate amount of righteous indignation. The show normally escapes publicity. Views tend to be less than insightful, although the principle of balance and the presence of rather old-fashioned personalities on the panel can provide lively expression of opposing views. Sometimes there are flashes of genuine debate.

The political discussion programme was recorded as anti-fascist campaigners protested outside Television Centre. Mr Griffin was booed at the start of the recording and accused of trying to “poison politics” as he was attacked by fellow panellists and the audience. He said he had been “demonised” and repeatedly denied saying things which have been attributed to him.

Early reactions to the show were captured by The Times

The corporation was delighted with the outcome, claiming that it justified the decision to include Mr Griffin. Mark Byford, the deputy director-general, said: “Members of the audience asked the kind of tough questions that mark Question Time out as the premier television programme where the public put the panellists on the spot.”
Comments on internet forums from television viewers accused the BBC of getting it wrong by allowing everyone to gang up on Mr Griffin and make him look like a victim.

It Doesn’t Matter

Call me one of those internet forum commentators. I was struck by several aspects of the programme. It seemed over-staged. The panellists took turns in conveying their revulsion for Mr Griffin and his political party, while stoutly justifying the rationale for sharing a public platform with him. The chairman encouraged the ‘ganging up’ process by taking part in it.

The audience were also pretty-well rehearsed. The hostility was of that of appropriate licence granted to licence holders. Not too subservient, emotional from time to time, but nothing too aggressive.

The media discussion after the show explored the rather anxious question posed at the end of the programme by the BBC. Is this an early Christmas present for the BNP?
Griffin’s fumbling performance might be replayed to some effect in the run-up to the next election. That was pretty much the BBC’s line. Here’s my alternative view: This is a 24-hour story, unlikely to have much longer-term impact. Question Time and Nick Griffin have done no more than share an Andy Warhol Moment.

… But what if Griffin had been more persuasive? I would like to think that the outcome would even then have been minimal.

Advertisements

3 Responses to Question Time and Nick Griffin Share an Andy Warhol Moment

  1. Tudor says:

    In trying to capture what happened in the QT debate, I ducked any clear analysis of why I reached the conclusion that it is a 24 hour news story. I would not have been impressed by this treatment in a student essay. [‘Lacks analysis ..not enough “map-testing” I might have commented]. I hope to have a more coherent view when I have had time to give the story more considered thought.

    Of course, there will be one empirical test: the rate of decline of the story as headline news.

  2. peter says:

    Something, somehow British about the whole thing. Griffin a kind of music hall fascist, couple of councillors, couple of MEPs – not a real French or Spanish fascist, you understand – just enough to get on the storyline, not enough to scare the children.
    Personally, I think Griffin is the kind who enjoys the fuss – almost any fuss – and the victimhood that goes with it. So the show went out. Robin Day’s angrily tramped the corridors of Broadcasting House, but the BBC got the show, got the viewing figures and looks less and less like a serious organization everyday.

  3. Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by Tudortweet: #KKK trending because of Nick Griffin’s TV appearance http://wp.me/p2C96-NY

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: