The Terror Approaches: Sir Fred pleads for mercy

Fred Goodwin and Tom McKillop

The leaders of failed financial institutes are being dragged out of their chateaux and paraded through the streets. I can hear the distant rumble of the tumbrels

Or, to shake off that fearsome image, let’s start with the show trial which took place today. Erstwhile heroes of capitalism were called to account by that Robespierre of the New labour Revolution, the Treasury Committee chairman John McFall

The BBC covered the proceedings

The former bosses of the two biggest UK casualties of the banking crisis have apologised “profoundly and unreservedly” for their banks’ failure.

Former Royal Bank of Scotland chief executive Sir Fred Goodwin told MPs on the Treasury Committee he “could not be more sorry” for what had happened.

The wrath of the prosecutors was reported in The Guardian

Sir Michael Fallon: “You [McKillop] were in charge of this board. You’ve destroyed a great British bank.”
John Thurso: “… I have rarely never heard such anger about an issue … And that’s because so many sound businesses are at risk of going under because they can’t get funding. 99.9% of my constituents believe that if a black hole opened up and every banker, and every derivatives trader and arbitrage trader fell into it, the world would be a better place ….”
George Mudie: “…The anger that the public feels is because you’re all in denial.”

But the jury remained unmoved. Chairman Tom McFall dismissed their grovelling pleas for mercy.

“They did give an apology and it seemed fulsome, but, as the session went on, I think they were drawing back from that and saying ‘Well, look, there were events outside our control’. If you ask me my opinion – yes, they were advised to do it (apologise). Was there a hint of arrogance still there? Absolutely.”

The Terror begins

I can’t get that image out of my mind’s eye. It took the French Revolution over a year to get down to the really brutal stuff, the show trials and public executions. But that was then. No chance of public executions here …

But the public anger might be as intense, and approval for meting out the harshest punishment possible on those accused.

So far, the most virulent attacks have showered down on the Leaders of the biggest financial institutions, and then The Government. But there is a more general wave of anger directed to all politicians, and that ‘least worse system’ of representative democracy.

And who next?

Business Leaders? Entrepreneurs? Foreign workers? “Make them walk naked ..stand in public with clown hats. ”

It is coming. The terror. And intellectuals will not escape scrutiny. What training did these people get to equip them to run a bank? Well, the answer is, a great deal of training. So let’s reserve a tumbrel for the leaders of business schools. Once again, the cry will be heard. What did you teach the MBAs at Harvard Business School?

And after that the tumbrel. Stop, enough. I want to get back into a state of denial.

About these ads

3 Responses to The Terror Approaches: Sir Fred pleads for mercy

  1. inseiffolliet says:

    am amused, slightly concerned and ultimately encouraged that we appear to mirror each others thoughts!

    i’m intrigued at the idea that individuals are to “blame” in all this rather than a societal abrigation of responsibility.

    here’s hoping for sanity rather than tumbrels eh?

  2. Tudor says:

    Yes, maybe we share some values about justice and responsibilities? I also agree about the blame dimension here. I was using the tumbrels as a figure of speech, but the sense of outrage, anger, and search for scapegoats are real and powerful emotions, maybe not all that different to those in other cultures and other times when threats overwhelm a culture, and also support the rise of ‘the wrong kind of leaders’. (Long sentence, but hope it’s still coherent).

    On the other hand, President Obama might have been found it tougher to gain election in less troubled times?

  3. Zickler says:

    The best article I’ve read on the very first day of the year. Thanks :)

    Happy new year

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,604 other followers

%d bloggers like this: